The Payment Edit

Regulation E error resolution

A free lesson on the error resolution clock, provisional credit, consumer liability, and how Reg E relates to Nacha rules.

Free lesson About 10 minutes · Course 3: Regulation E for Operations

What you will learn

  • What Regulation E covers, and what counts as an error
  • The error resolution clock, from notice to final credit
  • When provisional credit is required
  • Consumer liability for unauthorized transfers
  • How the Reg E clock relates to Nacha return windows

Related: ACH settlement and returns.

1. What Regulation E covers

Regulation E implements the Electronic Fund Transfer Act. It protects consumers who use electronic fund transfers (EFTs) on consumer accounts, such as ACH debits and credits, debit card purchases, ATM withdrawals, and many app-based transfers. It does not protect business accounts, which rely on the account agreement, Nacha rules, and state law. Wire transfers follow their own rules.

2. What counts as an error

Under 12 CFR 1005.11(a), errors include:

A routine balance inquiry, or a request for a copy of documentation for record-keeping, is not an error under the rule.

3. The consumer’s notice

The institution must follow the error resolution procedures when it receives notice no later than 60 days after it sends the periodic statement showing the problem. The notice can be oral or written. It must let the institution identify the consumer and the account and explain why the consumer believes there is an error. If the consumer calls, the institution may require written confirmation within 10 business days, but it must say so on the call and give the address.

4. The clock

StepDeadline
Notice receivedDay 0. The clock starts when the institution receives the notice, not when the transfer happened.
Finish the investigation, or provisionally creditWithin 10 business days of the notice
Tell the consumer about the provisional creditWithin 2 business days after providing it. State the amount and date, and give full use of the funds.
Investigation outer limit45 calendar days from the notice. It is 90 days for point-of-sale debit transactions, transfers initiated outside a state, and transfers within 30 days after the account’s first deposit.
New accountsThe 10-business-day periods become 20 business days when the error involves a transfer within 30 days after the first deposit.
After the investigationReport the results within 3 business days. If an error occurred, correct it within 1 business day of determining it.

Without a provisional credit, the institution must finish within 10 business days. The institution does not have to provisionally credit if it required written confirmation of an oral notice and did not receive it within 10 business days.

5. Worked example

A consumer calls on Friday, November 20, 2026 to dispute an ACH debit. This is a standard case, not a new account or a point-of-sale debit.

  • 10 business days: skipping the weekend and Thanksgiving, that is Monday, December 7, 2026. If the investigation is not done, the provisional credit is due by then, and the consumer is told within 2 business days after it is made.
  • 45-day outer limit: Monday, January 4, 2027.
  • If it were a 90-day case: Thursday, February 18, 2027.

Business days follow the institution’s own definition under Reg E, so confirm your calendar. Run your own dates in the Reg E timeline calculator.

6. If there is no error

If the institution decides there was no error, or a different error, it sends a written explanation and tells the consumer they may request the documents it relied on. If it debits a provisional credit, it must tell the consumer the date and amount. It must then honor checks, drafts, and preauthorized transfers for 5 business days after that notice, as long as it would have paid them had the provisional credit not been debited.

7. Liability for unauthorized transfers

Under 12 CFR 1005.6, a consumer’s liability for unauthorized transfers is capped when they notify the institution promptly.

These caps depend on the institution having given the required disclosures, and on an accepted access device where one is involved. Many ACH debit disputes involve no lost device, so the 60-day statement rule matters most there.

8. Reg E and Nacha: two separate clocks

Reg ENacha
ProtectsThe consumer, against the institutionThe ODFI and RDFI, in the ACH network
Clock startsWhen the institution receives the consumer’s noticeAt the settlement date
Unauthorized debitInvestigation and credit timelines aboveRDFI can return up to 60 calendar days after settlement, with a Written Statement of Unauthorized Debit

A consumer can dispute an ACH debit under Reg E even if the Nacha return window has closed. Missing the Nacha window does not end the institution’s Reg E obligations. Compare the two in Reg E vs. Nacha, and see the return windows in lesson 2.

9. Operations checklist

Key terms

Electronic fund transfer · error · provisional credit · business day · access device · Written Statement of Unauthorized Debit · periodic statement

Knowledge check

Educational content, not legal or compliance advice. Reg E is detailed, so confirm requirements against the regulation, the CFPB’s official interpretations, and your institution’s policies.

Related