The Payment Edit

ACH return codes and return windows

Look up ACH return reason codes, how long an RDFI has to send each one, and which returns count toward Nacha’s return rate thresholds.

CodeReasonReturn windowTypeNote

Return rate thresholds

Nacha monitors debit return rates by category: 0.5% unauthorized (R05, R07, R10, R11, R29, R51), 3% administrative or account data errors (R02, R03, R04), and 15% overall. Exceeding a threshold can prompt an inquiry.

“2 banking days” means the RDFI’s return must reach the ODFI by its opening on the second banking day after settlement of the original entry. “60 calendar days” is the extended window for unauthorized consumer debits, generally supported by a Written Statement of Unauthorized Debit (WSUD). This list shows commonly used codes, not every code. See Appendix Four of the Nacha Operating Rules for the full table.

Dishonored and contested returns

An ODFI that believes a return is wrong, for example untimely, a duplicate, or with field errors, can dishonor it. Per Nacha, the ODFI transmits the dishonored return within 5 banking days of the settlement date of the return entry. The RDFI can then contest or correct it within 2 banking days of the settlement date of the dishonored return. Nacha has asked the industry whether either timeframe should be shortened, and no change has been made. Nacha source

Coming March 17, 2028: R90

Nacha is adding R90, “Entry Returned Due to RDFI’s Sanctions Compliance Obligations.” R16 returns to “Account Frozen,” described as access restricted by RDFI action or legal action, with its OFAC reference removed. RDFIs must make a sanctions-related return available to the ODFI by the opening of business on the second banking day after their sanctions compliance determination. See the rule updates tracker for the checklist. Nacha source

Related